Tolerance Clause in a Letter of Credit

  • Auteur/autrice de la publication :
  • Post category:Uncategorized
  • Commentaires de la publication :0 commentaire

Flexibility in quantity, amount, or shipment under LC rules.


✅ What Is a Tolerance Clause in an LC?

A tolerance clause (also called margin clause or flexibility clause) is a provision in a Letter of Credit (LC) that allows a permitted variation in quantity, amount, weight, or value without causing the presentation to be non-compliant.

This clause recognizes that commercial shipments are not always exact down to the last kilogram, liter, or dollar.

It prevents rejection of documents when minor differences fall within an approved margin.


✅ Synonyms

  • Margin clause

  • Flexibility clause in LC


✅ Associated Terms

  • Documentary compliance

  • Partial shipments

  • Variations in quantity or value


✅ Why Tolerance Exists

Trade shipments often vary slightly due to:

  • Production fluctuation

  • Transport handling

  • Moisture loss or packing variation

  • Bulk commodities (grain, oil, sugar, metals, etc.)

Without a tolerance clause, even a small difference could result in discrepancy, delaying payment.


✅ Standard ICC UCP 600 Tolerance

According to UCP 600 – Article 30, unless the LC specifically prohibits it:

  • A ±10% tolerance is allowed on:

    • Quantity of goods

    • Unit price

    • Total amount

    • Weight or volume

Example:
If the LC calls for 100 MT of sugar, a shipment between 90 MT and 110 MT may be acceptable, provided unit price remains unchanged and total does not exceed LC limit unless permitted.


✅ How It Appears in an LC

Typical wording:

  • “±10% tolerance allowed”

  • “Up to 5% more or less acceptable”

  • “Quantity and value subject to 10% variation”

If the LC states “no tolerance” or “exact quantity only”, then even a small variation can be rejected.


✅ Benefits of a Tolerance Clause

Beneficiary (Seller)Applicant (Buyer)
Avoids document rejection for minor differencesPrevents over-shipment beyond contract
Faster paymentClear control of limits
Less pressure for perfect precisionTransparent commercial terms

It reduces disputes, accelerates payment, and keeps trade smooth.


✅ Common Use Cases

  • Bulk commodities (grain, sugar, cement, fertilizers, coal, oil, metals)

  • Agricultural products (where moisture or density can vary)

  • Manufactured goods with natural production variation

  • Large shipments where exact weight cannot be guaranteed

This clause is especially important where precision is physically impossible.


✅ What Tolerance Does Not Allow

  • Unauthorized additional shipments

  • Major changes in contract price

  • Goods different from those specified

  • Shipment outside allowed dates

  • Variation beyond the percentage stated

It protects flexibility — not abuse.


✅ Frequently Asked Questions

1. Does every LC include a tolerance clause?
No. Some are strict and require exact quantities.

2. What is the default tolerance if nothing is written?
UCP 600 generally allows ±10%, unless the LC says otherwise.

3. Does tolerance apply to price and quantity?
It can apply to both, unless the LC restricts it.

4. Can banks refuse documents within tolerance?
Not if they comply with UCP 600 and LC wording.

5. Is tolerance allowed in partial shipments?
Yes, unless the LC prohibits partial shipments.


✅ Conclusion

A tolerance clause provides essential flexibility in Letters of Credit, protecting both buyer and seller from unnecessary delays, disputes, and document rejection caused by minor, natural shipment variations.

In real logistics, nothing is perfectly exact.
This clause ensures the payment process remains efficient and compliant — even when the shipment is not precise to the decimal.

Laisser un commentaire